In 2017, Ugenti was the only Republican to oppose a 'Blue Lives Matter' bill that toughens penalties for assaulting off-duty police.[3]

In January 2019, she sponsored legislation which would prohibit voters who received early vote ballots from casting those votes at polling places before or on election day (they would only be allowed to cast them through mail). Election officials from both parties, as well as voting rights advocates, opposed the legislation, saying that it solves no problem and with some saying it amounted to voter suppression. In 2018, about 228,000 voters had cast their early vote ballots on election day itself, but would be prohibited from doing so under the proposed law.[citation needed]

Ugenti has sponsored a number of bills making it harder to put ballot initiatives up to voters.[4]

In 2021, she supported legislation that would require voters in Arizona who vote by mail to include identification paperwork along with their ballots.[5]